Skip to content

Industry

Seoul Court Dismisses Belift Lab and Source Music Damages Suits Against Min Hee-jin

The Seoul Western District Court on Nov. 13 (KST) dismissed Belift Lab's 2 billion won suit and Source Music's 500 million won suit against former ADOR CEO Min Hee-jin, along with Min's 5 billion won countersuit, ruling her remarks were expressions of opinion.

By 2FC NEWSROOM · Published

Former ADOR CEO Min Hee-jin speaking at a press conference, in a Yonhap file photo
Image: Yonhap News

A Seoul court has thrown out the first-instance civil cases that pitted two HYBE labels against former ADOR CEO Min Hee-jin. On Nov. 13 (KST), the Seoul Western District Court dismissed Belift Lab's 2 billion won damages claim and Min's 5 billion won countersuit, Yonhap and the Korea JoongAng Daily reported. The court also dismissed Source Music's separate 500 million won suit the same day, the JoongAng said.

Belift Lab, which manages ILLIT, had sued Min over her April 2024 press conference remarks that the group and its branding copied NewJeans and ADOR. The court held that those comments were expressions of opinion, not statements of fact. Yonhap and the JoongAng both report the court treated the remarks as subjective opinion. The JoongAng quotes Presiding Judge Kim Jin-young as saying similar comparisons were already circulating online, and that punishing such opinions could chill criticism in popular culture.

Min's countersuit — which argued that Belift Lab's rebuttal video and statements had harmed her, and asked the company to publish a correction — was also dismissed. The JoongAng reported that the court likewise treated Belift Lab's rebuttal as opinion and rejected Min's claim that NewJeans' creation could be attributed to her alone. In the Source Music case, the judge found it difficult to prove her remarks about debut timing and trainee selection were false, and said a 'bully' comment had been directed at HYBE, not at Source Music.

Both labels said they would appeal. A separate criminal complaint Belift Lab filed against Min is still pending; police referred her and two then-ADOR vice presidents to prosecutors in October on suspicion of defamation and obstruction of business, Yonhap and the JoongAng reported.

Confirmed

  • On Nov. 13 (KST), the Seoul Western District Court dismissed Belift Lab's 2 billion won (about US$1.5 million) damages suit against former ADOR CEO Min Hee-jin and also dismissed Min's 5 billion won countersuit against Belift Lab (Yonhap, Korea JoongAng Daily).
  • The same court the same day dismissed Source Music's separate 500 million won suit against Min (Korea JoongAng Daily).
  • The court found Min's April 2024 remarks comparing ILLIT and NewJeans to be expressions of subjective opinion rather than assertions of fact, and emphasized broad freedom of expression in popular culture and the arts (Korea JoongAng Daily, Yonhap).
  • Belift Lab and Source Music said they would appeal (Korea JoongAng Daily).
  • A separate criminal case remains: Yonhap and Korea JoongAng Daily report that Seoul Yongsan Police referred Min and two then-ADOR vice presidents to prosecutors in October on suspicion of defamation and obstruction of business.

Reported by other outlets

  • Korea JoongAng Daily quotes Presiding Judge Kim Jin-young of the 12th Civil Division as saying there had already been online discussion about similarities between ILLIT and NewJeans before Min's comments, and that imposing legal liability for such opinions could restrict criticism in the pop-culture industry.
  • Belift Lab said it was 'deeply regrettable that the court effectively ruled that there are victims but no perpetrators' and that it would appeal, according to Korea JoongAng Daily. Source Music said the ruling 'turned a blind eye to conduct that inflicted irreparable psychological harm on artists who were not direct parties to the dispute' and also said it would appeal.
  • The suits stemmed from Min's April 25, 2024 press conference, in which she accused HYBE of copying NewJeans in creating ILLIT and also made remarks about Source Music and the debut order with LE SSERAFIM (Korea JoongAng Daily).

Conflicts of interest: Yonhap's English dispatch focuses on the Belift Lab suit and Min's countersuit and does not mention the Source Music ruling in that item. Korea JoongAng Daily reports all three dismissals, including Source Music's 500 million won claim, in the same first-instance sitting. This article attributes the Source Music result to the JoongAng.

Follow @2fastcloud on X

Spot an error? See our corrections policy.